Sunday, February 26, 2006

Casus riotus 

Apart from the fighting in Iraq, which has been an extended version of the same fighting that we have seen for months, what should we make of the difference in reactions to the Danish cartoons and the bombing of Al Askari Mosque? Haitham Sabbah, a Palestinian who blogs in English from Bahrain, erupts in a cri de coeur:
Protest… Syria, Lebanon, Egypt, Libya, Sudan, Pakistan, Iran, just name it…. everywhere Muslims filled the streets defying their government, and decrying the evil in the West. They call it Denmark, or the American Satan, or whatever. The reason? The infamous Danish cartoon.

Was that the greatest affront to Islam in recent decades? What about the more direct attack on Islam and Muslims? How about the bombing of a 1200 year old mosque? Yes, the bombing of the Shia Shrine in Samarra. How about the slaughter of hundreds of Muslims? How about burning and destroying dozens of Sunni mosques in Iraq as retaliation? Why is this not more offensive of these stupid cartoons? Isn’t Islam the Religion of Peace? Where are the street riots?

It was quiet in Muslim world… It is hot and bloody in Iraq!

Violence is the time-honored way of solving any dispute, political or not. Diplomacy is not respected. It’s a sign of weakness. This is how it looks now. Isn’t this a far greater sin for Muslims to kill each other and burn mosques and Koran than a disrespectful picture of the Prophet?

This isn’t going to get better. More and more it seems we’re dealing not with a small minority of kooks, but an epidemic of extremism that is bloodthirsty and violent at its core. Call it Sunni, call it Shi’a, call it Wahhabi’s, call it Batheist, call it whatever, I don’t care. It’s all revolving around the nation of Islam and Muslims.

Worse than the colorful infamous cartoons are the ‘human flesh cartoons’. The cartoons that are rioting our streets blindly. The human flesh cartoons that are killing Muslims, bombing and burning mosques. The cartoons which is blaming it on occupation and Israel. Did Israel send troops to burn our mosques? Did the American Satan send troops to kill our Imams and burn our Qur’an?

Shame on you Muslims. Shame that you protest over the Dane cartoons yet shut-up on the Human/Muslim flesh cartoons.

Not that I’m not asking Muslim to go out in protests around the Islamic world. But wondering why Muslims in Iraq are not Muslims enough? Why can they protest against a cartoon, yet do not respect their brother Iraqi Muslims? A tomb build of stones, covered with golden flakes is more important than hundred of slaughtered Muslim, by Muslims all in the name of ISLAM!

Read the comments -- apart from a few shallow American Bush-haters, there is some interesting debate among educated, cosmopolitan Muslims about the state of their own religion.

Haitham Sabbah's blog is a tough read if you are as strong a supporter of our national policy in the region as I am, but that is no excuse for staying away. He writes about all sorts of things from a perspective that would surely benefit American blog readers.


By Anonymous Betty Cracker, at Sun Feb 26, 09:15:00 AM:

Thanks for the link to Sabbah's blog -- I wasn't familiar with it. I've been reading Healing Iraq lately and have heard a similar note of dispair.

Even William F. Buckley is ready to throw in the towel on Iraq. I begin to think it's all over but the shouting. I'm not happy about it, even though I opposed the war from the beginning. But that's how it looks to me.  

By Blogger sirius_sir, at Sun Feb 26, 12:54:00 PM:

I wonder if we aren't seeing the discrediting of Islamism played out in real time. How do ordinary Muslims square the attacks on these mosques with the supposed precepts of their religion? Legitimate speculation suggests al-Qaeda or al-Sadr or Iran may be behind the mosque bombing in Samarra, meanwhile attempts to blame America for every ill in the Muslim world gain less and less traction. Could it be that average Muslims are beginning to catch on and see manipulation at work behind these attacks on their religion? First there were Danish imams telling the world they thought a pig-snouted man looked like the prophet Mohammed, and blaming their apostasy on cartoonists. Now suspicion arises that so-called defenders of the faith have attacked Islam in a similarly cynical manner again. Haitham Sabbah is asking some interesting questions. There's no reason to think other ordinary Muslims aren't just as capable of such questioning or, similarly, understanding what is really going on.  

By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sun Feb 26, 11:08:00 PM:

Well, the mosque bombing is looking to be an inside job:

On who is responsible for the recent bombing of the Golden Mosque in Samarra:

MOWAFFAK AL-RUBAIE, IRAQ'S NATIONAL SECURITY ADVISER: Well, the blueprint of that unfortunate event, the blueprints of Al Qaida in Iraq is there.

It's the same design, the same method, the same objective they wanted to achieve, which is a civil war. They wanted to drive a wedge between the two communities in Iraq, between the Shia and Sunnis. And they've been trying this for the last two and a half years and they failed miserably in this.

And I think also this is one of the most horrible, really terrible attacks on the doctrine, on the belief of the largest community in Iraq. And still, Iraqi people have proven that they've gone through this difficulty yet again and they have shown the Al Qaida and the outside world that they will never be driven to the civil war.

BLITZER: So when you say Al Qaida in Iraq, you mean Abu Musab al-Zarqawi? Is that right?

AL-RUBAIE: That's absolutely right.

It's the same organization of Al Qaida, this international terrorist organization, and one -- the branch of it in Iraq is Abu Musab al-Zarqawi leading this terrible attack, terrorist attacks against our people.

BLITZER: Have your security or police forces...

AL-RUBAIE: And against our -- and against...

BLITZER: ... arrested anyone?

AL-RUBAIE: Well, we have arrested 10 people. Four from the guards of the Golden Tomb (ph) shrine. And six -- there were in the city of Samarra, just moved in and rented a place. Six young people there. So we are investigating them.

We have a very -- there are two leads and these leads are very, very good in our investigation. And we will reveal this in the very near future, inshallah.


By Blogger sunguh5307, at Sun Feb 26, 11:14:00 PM:

Too soon to be a bonafide discredit to Islam. But the dissonance takes a lot of effort to maintain. I don't see a reformation anywhwere, so they'll have to cling to their victimization for some time to come.

Still, it's nice to hear that it's not all blocked out. Unless that's why I can't access the page- is the link bad or is the server down? Or did somebody come under pressure to take down the site?  

By Anonymous Anonymous, at Sun Nov 09, 11:01:00 PM:


Post a Comment

This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?