Thursday, September 23, 2010
The powers-that-be at Sesame Street have pulled this video of Elmo and Katy Perry because it is "too racy." Maybe I'm a bad parent, but I don't see it. You decide (and, yes, totally SFW -- duh, it's Sesame Street):
All together now: They said that if I voted for John McCain the prudes would censor Sesame Street, and they were right!
Not my editorial choice, but not horrible.
I thought about it. It's the kind of dress a 3-6 year old girl might wear to a wedding party or some kind of nice event where they would enjoy dressing up like a 16 year old or older which, though I'm a man, I could see being fun for many of them (I think shoulder straps would have been better certainly editorially, but compared to what 3-6 year old girls DO wear out on the street with their parents, this is an elegant outfit).
I guess I only felt like the song implied a physical relationship between a girl and a boy (the muppet as substitute) that was hot and cold. I had a crush on a girl in pre-school (and my pre-school teacher) so I know that starts at 4 in it's very innocent way. But still, it's hard to watch it be shall we say fomented on Sesame Street however subtly without cringing. I don't know - it's a very personal viewpoint.
Final verdict; I'd have directed the video differently, shoulder straps and having the hot and cold question be about playing baseball or going to the movies or something.
My kids are way beyond Sesame Street age but my recollection is that many of the musician-performer "sing-along with muppet pieces" were of better quality than this one, with some scattered classics along the way. Not sure if it's the music/voice, the outfit, the muddled message or what, but it's cringe-worthy. The kids won't be worse off for missing it.
I have 4 kids....10, 7, 4 and 2. They are all better off missing this one. Her outfit is too risque for the SS crowd. I also disapprove of putting her on the show when the songs she sings are totally inappropriate for this age group.
Four kids! Congratulations, but, wow that's a lot of work. I bet you folks catch every bug there is... We have three, but they're almost all grown up now (one left at home, two at college) and while we're excited to see what life brings us next we're also a little worried: after all, we've had non-stop action for a long time and it's all about to end. Enjoy your kids!
Dawnfire82, if anon 4:21 has four kids, monastery living is unlikely scenario. Perhaps just trying to avoid introducing "nunnery" style wardrobe to the under 10 crowd.
But hey, keep cruising the parks. It's a free country.
Dawnfire82: No monastery for us...but we try really hard to let the kids be kids as long as possible. So, for our family, that means they dress their ages and we monitor what they watch and listen to.
We've seen worse in parks, sure. But we don't have to invite that crap into our home.
Seriously, guys...if you are old enough to appreciate the hooters, then you really have bigger problems if you are still watching Sesame Street!!
This is the kind of moron-think that leads to the suspension oflittle boys from kindergarten for sexual harassment!
Face it, lefties, children are different...just like men, women, blacks, whites, gays and grandparents...people ARE DIFFERENT, forchrissakes!!!
Appropriateness is not a unitary item, and changes from occasion to occasion. That is part of the social skills we teach children from earliest ages. It is a different dress when it is worn on older sister's music video that the 5 y/o watches over her shoulder than it is on a program that implicitly states "This is for you. This is your show."
It's a cute song. It's a cute idea. It's not a dress your kid's kindergarten teacher should be wearing to kindergarten, nor even to the school talent show. If she wore it in a community theater play and her students went to see it, no big deal.
5 sons, BTW. Four grown.