<$BlogRSDUrl$>

Monday, March 13, 2006

Unleash the Davids 

The President has finally prevailed upon the intelligence establishment to release the documents captured in Afghanistan and Iraq. The entire world will be free to translate them and interpret them. If John Negroponte gets them out as quickly as we hope -- the "details" still need to be decided -- this should be a fascinating experiment in distributed, spontaneous documentary analysis. An "army of Davids", working in the open, will learn more from these documents in weeks than the United States intelligence apparatus has been able to divine in years.

2 Comments:

By Anonymous Anonymous, at Tue Mar 14, 01:59:00 PM:

To be merely but not substantively trivial, precisely what is the chain of custody of each document?
There was an Iraqi disinformation campaign going on; who can say if a statement is true or fake only from reading it.
And the DOD is still conducting the struggle via planted "information".
To decide what one document actually means when it is not a comprehensive document in a matrix of communications could take many researchers many months to decipher each batch and then redecipher based on some subsequent batch. And that's for english language documents. Think about how imprecise language affects email and discussion postings.
In 1992 I worked at a day job with an afterhours Japanese history grad student who was doing initial translation of WW2 documents microfilmed by the U.S. Navy of Imperial Navy files.
I believe this super-secretive Administration is just trying to muddy the waters, and provide more "proof" to spin for their acolytes.  

By Blogger Dawnfire82, at Tue Mar 14, 08:15:00 PM:

The administration is publishing thousands of pages of documents that by all rights should be classified for the next 8 years or so, but they are super-secretive? Astounding. I also admire your use of quotations to subtly imply falsehood or doubt. It speaks of your "wit" and "insight."  

Post a Comment


This page is powered by Blogger. Isn't yours?